In recent years, studies of how such animals make these sorts of decisions is often framed in terms of their ability to respond to climate change or other unexpected manmade changes. This is not necessarily easy to study in wild animals that live on land, but studying cetaceans adds another layer of difficulty. Most obviously, that's because they are out and about in the water, an environment that's less ideal for humans than, say, the grasslands of Africa. But it also doesn't help that cetaceans have unusually complex social lives that can be difficult to entangle.
However, recent years have given us a new tool to investigate cetacean behaviour without the need for boats to stay close to the animals. Since around the turn of the century, scientists studying cetaceans have turned increasingly to the use of drones or, to be more technical, "unmanned aerial vehicles".
There are basically three different categories of drones in use here, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. The most expensive are long-distance, high-altitude fixed-wing drones, which are limited both by cost and by aviation regulations that prevent them from causing a hazard to other aircraft. Even so, the fact that they can stay in the air for 24 hours or more at a time and travel significant distances means that they may be the only option if what you want to do is count the occurrence of animals over a wide area.
Then there are the low-altitude fixed-wing drones, which operate for only a couple of hours or so, but are much quieter and can get closer to their targets without disturbing them. These are best if you want to look at individual whales within a pod, or if you are counting animals confined to a small area, such as seals resting on rocks.
And then there's the sort of drone we are perhaps most familiar with, the small short-range ones with the VTOL rotors. These are much cheaper than the others, but they don't last very long, so you have to be relatively close to your target to use them. On the other hand, the fact that they can hover means that you are going to get much better pictures of whatever you're looking at, and they are highly manoeuvrable compared with the fixed-wing sort. If what you want to do is observe behaviour, the disadvantage of short range and operating time is likely to be well worth it - especially as these are the cheapest sort of drone.
Killer whales (Orcinus orca) are the largest species of dolphin and are found in virtually all the world's oceans. They live in large, extended groups, based around matrilineal descent, and the fact that they live in so many different marine environments means that they are useful for studying how environment and ecology affect decision-making. Most studies of their behaviour and leadership strategies, however, have been conducted on those living in the eastern North Pacific, close to America. Even here, however, there is variation in the diets and foraging strategies of different groups, and this is known to affect behaviour more widely.
Recently, a new study has been published looking at the killer whales off the coast of Norway. These have an unusually mixed and varied diet, indicating flexible hunting strategies. The large size of the population, however, has previously hampered attempts to separate individual groups to identify the leaders within them. The new study got around this by looking at the groups that use a particular partially enclosed location, returning year after year.
This is the Hardangerfjord, at 180 km (110 miles), the second-longest fjord in Norway. It lies between Bergen and Stavanger, consisting of a wide main channel that splits into two in a T-shape. Small villages dot the shoreline, with only a few larger towns, and an industry based on a mixture of fisheries and tourism.
The researchers conducted their study between February and April 2025, using quadcopters operated, in most cases, from the shoreline to observe the whales in their natural habitat. They identified individual whales from a catalogue of those known to live in the area, distinguishing them by scars, fin shape and other characteristics. This, crucially, allowed them to sex the animals to determine which sex, if either, had the most decision-making power.
The study's primary measure of decision-making in the killer whales was when they chose to take deep dives to hunt for prey. It is, perhaps, unsurprising that it was the females, and especially the older females, that made the first move, with the rest of the family group following within a minute of her doing so - and, in around a third of cases, within just 10 seconds. It's not an absolute rule, because younger females and, even more rarely, males did occasionally start the process off, but they were very much in the minority.
It may also be worth noting that the whale starting the dive was more likely to be at the front of the group than in the middle. We see something similar when land-based herd animals choose to move, but those have the obvious advantage that the animal in front has the best view of where they are going, which doesn't really apply to whales diving. But, if you want to take the lead, it likely helps if others can see what you're doing.
Studies in the eastern North Pacific have shown that menopausal whales are most likely to lead the dives there, and this group didn't have any of those. Nonetheless, the fact that it's the older females who call the shots doubtless reflects much the same process - just as with elephants, the wisdom and experience that comes with age is apparently respected by their younger peers.
As to why females may be more influential than males (when that's generally not true of humans, even today) it may be notable that the only adult female that never initiated a dive during the study was the one who, at the time, did not have an infant to care for. So it may be that the experience and responsibility of caring for a child makes killer whales not just better mothers, but better at knowing what is good for the whole group.
The importance of maternal bonding as an element in killer whale groups was further supported by analysis of the social behaviour observed in the recordings. This included surfacing simultaneously at the end of a dive and instances of physical contact between individuals. In both cases, this was most likely between mothers and their offspring under the age of five years, and never seen, for example, between two juveniles over the age of five. Even after excluding suckling infants, this remains the case, doubtless showing mothers teaching their children how to forage as well as general social bonding that remains, at some level, into adulthood.
[Photo by Maarten Visser, from Wikimedia Commons.]
.jpg)
No comments:
Post a Comment